Main features of the D/P payment method in international trade - ASL LAW

The D/P (Documents against Payment) payment method is one of the common payment methods in Vietnam and internationally, enabling parties involved in international trade to lớn conduct transactions with transparency and accuracy, ensuring the interests of each buổi tiệc ngọt. However, due to lớn its relatively recent introduction, there are some operational and personnel management gaps in implementing the payment methods.

In Vietnam, a significant nationwide issue arose in 2022 related to lớn a cooperative export giảm giá khuyến mãi of 100 containers of cashew nuts from several Vietnamese enterprises to lớn Italy, using the D/P payment method.

In principle, after completing the procedures and preparing the documents, the exporting company would submit the documents to lớn the ngân hàng in Vietnam. Subsequently, the Vietnamese ngân hàng would expedite the delivery of these documents to lớn the importing ngân hàng in the foreign country (Italy – EU). Upon payment by the buyer to lớn the importing ngân hàng, the original documents would be released. The buyer could then go to lớn the port, present the documents, and receive the goods. Finally, the importing ngân hàng would transfer the funds to lớn the Vietnamese ngân hàng, which, in turn, would transfer the funds to lớn the Vietnamese exporting company, completing the transaction.

Bạn đang xem: Main features of the D/P payment method in international trade - ASL LAW

Issues arose when the company sent the first batch of containers along with the documents. During the process, the SWIFT code (a unique code used in global interbank transactions) of the buyer’s ngân hàng in Turkey, as instructed by the Vietnamese ngân hàng, changed, indicating inconsistency in the buyer’s ngân hàng.

Later, after the ngân hàng believed to lớn be the buyer’s ngân hàng received the original documents, they notified that the buyer was not their customer and returned the documents without specifying the return method. The Vietnamese ngân hàng tried contacting multiple times but received no response.

For the documents sent to lớn Italy, the receiving ngân hàng informed that they had received a copy of the documents, not the originals. Vietnamese exporting companies faced the risk of losing some containers, as whoever possessed the original documents could claim the goods at the port.

At that time, Vietnamese businesses lost control over 36 containers of cashew nuts, valued at 163 billion VND. Thanks to lớn the rapid actions of the involved banks and the tư vấn of the Vietnamese government, over three months later, Vietnamese enterprises regained control over 100 containers and incurred only minor expenses such as storage and transportation fees. They also sold the rescued cashews at a discounted price to lớn recover some losses rather than vãn losing everything.

Risks from the D/P Payment Method?

Following the incident, many experts pointed out that the risk of exporting 100 containers of cashew nuts stemmed from the use of the D/P (Documents against Payment) payment method. Compared to lớn the Letter of Credit (L/C) payment method, which involves documentary credits, D/P is less complex but carries more inherent risks.

In the case of cashew nut exports, under the D/P method, Vietnamese exporting companies would send the documents to lớn the shipping company after completing export procedures, and the documents would then be transferred to lớn the selling ngân hàng in Vietnam. The Vietnamese ngân hàng was responsible for expeditiously delivering these documents to lớn the importing ngân hàng in the destination country. Subsequently, the importing buổi tiệc ngọt would make payment to lớn the importing ngân hàng and receive the documents, allowing them to lớn claim the goods at the port. The importing ngân hàng would then transfer the funds to lớn the Vietnamese ngân hàng, completing the transaction.

However, due to lớn a lack of verification and strict monitoring of the identity and reputation of the importing buổi tiệc ngọt, Vietnamese companies lost control over 36 sets of documents for 36 containers of cashew nuts. This number could have increased if Vietnamese companies had not reacted promptly, leading to lớn the suspension of the shipment of the remaining 64 batches.

Under the D/P payment method, losing control over the documents means that whoever possesses the lost documents can claim and take the goods without making any payment. If the entity possessing the lost documents is not the original buyer, the importing buổi tiệc ngọt in Italy would not make payment to lớn Vietnamese companies without the documents, resulting in total losses for the Vietnamese companies.

In this case, the importing buổi tiệc ngọt is currently under suspicion of intentional fraud, and there may not be any genuine interest from any buổi tiệc ngọt in Italy to lớn import the cashew nut shipment.

Xem thêm: Học phí trường ĐH Giao thông Vận tải - Phân hiệu TP.HCM

The D/P payment method, though widely applied in Vietnam before the cashew nut incident, carries relatively high risks as it does not mandate the buyer to lớn deposit funds in the ngân hàng for the payment. For instance, if a 10% deposit is required, the buyer would need to lớn deposit 10 billion VND when importing a batch worth 100 billion VND. This security deposit, coupled with other requirements such as providing tax identification numbers, ngân hàng tài khoản information, and representative details, would enhance verification and reduce risks for the seller.

Given the revealed shortcomings of the D/P method, experts suggest that the L/C payment method would help Vietnamese companies minimize risks to lớn the maximum extent. When using L/C, banks act as intermediaries, thoroughly examining the presented documents and only releasing payment if all conditions are met. Without careful examination, the intermediary ngân hàng (which may include both the buyer’s and seller’s banks) assumes all risks and is responsible for compensating for any damages, thereby minimizing risks for both the exporting and importing parties.

The True Risks: Trust and Credibility

Although L/C (Letter of Credit) is considered more secure than vãn D/P, the reality in Vietnam, as per information from the Vietnamese Ministry of Industry and Trade, is that international trade transactions using L/C tài khoản for less than vãn 5% of the total transactions due to lớn its complexity. One of the conditions deterring businesses from using L/C is the requirement for a deposit.

This is because when a deposit is made, the funds are immobilized in the ngân hàng and cannot be utilized by the business. Buyers, especially in cases where deposits are as high as 50% or the entire value of the transaction, exert pressure on sellers to lớn avoid using L/C. If sellers tự not comply, buyers may seek alternative sellers who have trust in the buyer’s credibility.

However, irrespective of the payment method used, risks exist for all parties involved in international trade. Currently, there is no payment method in the market that is entirely risk-free, including methods such as T/T (Telegraphic Transfer), D/P, or L/C.

The most crucial aspect of international cross-border payments in import-export is the trustworthiness of the parties involved. This trust should be verified through years of operation and confirmed by reputable international organizations. Vietnamese businesses need to lớn proactively kiểm tra the credibility of the importing buổi tiệc ngọt before signing contracts and choosing a payment method, avoiding excessive reliance on intermediaries.

In the cashew nut incident, Vietnamese companies had no direct liên hệ or detailed information about the buyer, as all agreements were conducted through an intermediary company. After the incident, information about the Italian buyers revealed small, unclear, and even inactive businesses, raising suspicions of fraud.

Thus, the actual risk in international trade lies not in the payment method but in the trust between partners. The cashew nut incident will undoubtedly be a valuable lesson for Vietnamese businesses as Vietnam engages in increasingly high-value international transactions.

Xem thêm: "The Letter C" in the English Alphabet

When a crisis occurs, what businesses need to lớn pay more attention to lớn is maintaining composure and considering how to lớn resolve the situation with the tư vấn of experienced and highly skilled units. Vietnamese businesses were able to lớn minimize the damage in the cashew nut crisis thanks to lớn their timely response and assistance from various units. Swift actions, such as requesting shipping companies to lớn halt transportation, redirecting shipments back to lớn Vietnam, and involving relevant authorities in Vietnam to lớn liên hệ the embassy of the importing country, played a crucial role.

With the help of such units can the cashew nut crisis serves as a ‘profound’ but not ‘excessively costly’ lesson for Vietnamese businesses.

ASL LAW is the top-tier Vietnam law firm for litigation and dispute resolution. If you need any advice, please liên hệ us for further information or collaboration.

***Other service of ASL LAW – full service Vietnam law firm ***
Retainer service to lớn enterprises International trademark registration
Oversea investment consultancy for Vietnamese enterprisesPatent in Vietnam
PCT Patent in Vietnam PCT Patent Vietnam Entry
Intellectual property services (Vietnam IP Firm) Vietnam Patent Agent
Trademark in Vietnam Vietnam Patent Firm
Vietnam Trademark Agent Patent translation in Vietnam
How to lớn register trademark in Vietnam Vietnam Patent Translation Agent
Copyright in Vietnam Vietnam IP Firm
Vietnam Trademark Vietnam IP Agent
Notes to lớn company formation in VietnamM&A
How to lớn open company in VietnamBanking & financial services
Open representative office in VietnamContract consultancy
Establish company in VietnamEmployment and labor
Corporate services in VietnamLitigation and dispute resolution
Vietnam Law FirmFranchise in Vietnam
Vietnam Antidumping Law Firm Vietnam Franchise registration
Vietnam countervailing law firm Vietnam Business Law Firm
Vietnam Real estate law firm Vietnam construction law firm
Law firm in Hanoi Law Firm in Ho Chi Minh



Bách khoa toàn thư mở Wikipedia

Một số công thức tính toán trong địa lý

Một số công thức tính toán trong địa lý: MỘT SỐ CÔNG THỨC TÍNH TOÁN TRONG ĐỊA LÝ 1. Tính độ che phủ rừng. - Đơn vị: % VD: Tính độ che phủ rừng nước ta năm 1943 biết diện tích rừng lúc đó là 142500km2, diện tích cả nước là 331212 km2. 2. Tính tỉ trọng trong cơ cấu. - Đơn vị: % VD: Bài tập 2 trang 86